I haven’t been out of high school for that long, but I’ll admit to becoming moderately self conscious about my age after reading this story in the New York Times about students hugging one another in greeting.
Back in my day (all of seven years ago), a kiss on the cheek sufficed for greeting close friends of the same gender, while one of those awkward, weak-jointed hugs that I yell at people for giving me now was reserved for greeting friends of the opposite sex. I don’t know if I’d have a problem with it if I were in high school at present, but the idea of bear hugging everyone you walk past in the halls strikes me as more than a little odd.
Still, I know it’s tempting to accuse the administrators who are trying to clamp down on hallway hugging and adults who find themselves uneasy with the practice of being akin to the thought-police and turn the ban on hugging in high school into a civil rights issue.
It’s not, for any number of reasons. First because, as I complained about vociforously while crusing the halls as a public school student, you essentially turn over 90% of your rights when you walk onto school grounds. They can’t beat you or deny you medical care, but beyond that, they can search your locker, confiscate your bookbag and–as is looking more likely considering the recent oral arguments before the Supreme Court–perform invasive and humiliating cavity searches if they suspect you of packing contraband Sudafed.
But beyond that, we do a disservice to young people if we insist on considering them the same as adults. We don’t allow ~75% of high school students to vote. 50% can’t drive. 100% can’t drink (legally, of course). Schools serve in loco parentis in a way your office or place of employment does not.
As a 25 -year-old, I am very nearly a fully formed person, well aware of what I think and believe and not altogether too concerned with speaking my mind, regardless of who is hurt or put off by what I say.
As a 15-year-old, I was relatively sure of what I thought, trying to figure out what I believed, and absolutely terrified of offending–or being disliked–by anyone.
If someone I didn’t particularly like came up to me today and asked me for a hug, I’d refuse. If someone I didn’t particularly like walked up to me ten years ago, arms outstretched, I’d have held my nose and hugged them back, terrified that my rebuff would do incalculable damage to my standing within my social sphere.
When adults cave to peer pressure, we chastise them and ask them why they didn’t know better. Why they didn’t stand up for themselves. We never ask that of young people. We assume that the peer pressure an adult feels on a daily basis dwarfs the pressure students endure. And it generally does.
I think Matt Yglesias is right in noting that Sarah Kershaw writes her Times article like a researcher studying the social habits of aliens, and most of her story is hilarious, if only for the quotes from administrators and teachers which, despite the fact that I’ve aged a decade, sound as ridiculous now as they did when I was 15. He pulls this quote:
Comforting as the hug may be, principals across the country have clamped down. “Touching and physical contact is very dangerous territory,” said Noreen Hajinlian, the principal of George G. White School, a junior high school in Hillsdale, N.J., who banned hugging two years ago. “It was needless hugging — they are in the hallways before they go to class. It wasn’t a greeting. It was happening all day.”
But he left out the quote that immediately preceeded it:
“If somebody were to not hug someone, to never hug anybody, people might be just a little wary of them and think they are weird or peculiar,” said Gabrielle Brown, a freshman at Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School in Manhattan.
That’s the problem with hugging in high schools, and why administrators have a compelling reason to put an end to it or, and I think more appropriately, curtail its frequency. Its the same reason, though obviously on a much smaller level, that we don’t allow prayer in schools. At the end of the day, some kids just don’t want to do it, and they shouldn’t have to face any negative consequences for that.